Soups - $9

Minestrone

- a classic Italian soup with pasta, beans and veggies.

Soup of the Day

- our chefs daily special that will dazzle your taste buds.

Appetizers

Mozzarella en carozza- $11

- fresh mozzarella lightly battered and fried to perfection with our homemade San Marzano sauce.


Mussels marinara or in white wine- $12

- local mussels in our homemade San Marzano sauce or in a white wine broth.


Fried Calamari- $12

- locally caught calamari lightly breaded and fried to perfection with sauce and sliced cherry peppers.


Rice Balls- $9

- homemade with our fresh San Marzano sauce and fresh grated grana padana.


Meatballs with fresh ricotta-$9

- our fresh baked meatballs in our homemade San Marzano sauce with fresh ricotta.


Salads

La Caprese Salad- $10

- our classic with mozzarella, tomato and basil with a balsamic glaze.


Classic Wedge- $12

- this classic iceberg with a buttermilk dressing and fresh pancetta.


Classic Caesar Salad- $12

- romaine lettuce, croutons with lemon juice, olive oil, Worcestershire sauce, garlic, Dijon mustard, Parmesan cheese, and black pepper.


House Salad- $6

- fresh lettuce, tomato, cucumber and croutons with your choice of dressings

Add:

Chicken- $6

Shrimp- $8

Pasta

Spaghetti with Meatballs- $18

- an Italian classic made to order with our baked meatballs and San Marzano sauce.


Orecchiette Bolognese- $18

- bell shaped pasta with our homemade San Marzano Bolognese meat sauce.


Fettuccine Alfredo- $18

- another Italian classic made with our freshly made Alfredo sauce.  

Add Chicken + $6


Penne a la Vodka- $18

- Made with our homemade a la vodka sauce with fresh cream.  

Add Chicken +$6

Linguini with fresh clams- $20

- linguini pasta with fresh local clams in a savory broth.


Bucatini Leonardo- $19

- bucatini pasta with a garlic sherry anchovy sauce with cherry peppers.

Italian Specialties

Mom’s Baked Ziti- $19

- a hundred year old family recipe with baby ziti, fresh sautéed ground beef, sausage fresh fluffy ricotta and mozzarella in our homemade San Marzano sauce baked to perfection.


Mom’s Eggplant Parm- $19

- thin cut fresh eggplant lightly battered and smothered in our homemade San Marzano sauce and grated grana padana cheese baked to perfection.


Mom’s Lasagna- $19

- made with fresh fresh sautéed ground beef, sausage fresh fluffy ricotta and mozzarella in our homemade San Marzano sauce baked to perfection.

12” Brick Oven Pizza - $14

Margarita
Pepperoni
Sausage & Meatball
Vegetarian


Chicken

Chicken Parmigiana- $22

- fresh chicken breast fried to perfection and smothered in our homemade San Marzano sauce and parmigiana cheese.


Chicken Piccata- $22

- medallions of chicken breast sautéed in our classic piccata sauce with capers.


Chicken Marsala- $22

- medallions of chicken breast sautéed in our classic marsala sauce with fresh mushrooms.


Veal

Veal Parmigiana- $32

- On the bone veal lightly breaded veal smothered in our homemade San Marzano sauce and parmigiana cheese.


Veal Cutlet Milanese- $32

- On the bone veal lightly battered and fried layered with arugula, tomatoes and an olive oil vinaigrette.


Veal Piccata- $24

- medallions of bone in veal sautéed in our classic piccata sauce with capers.


Veal Marsala- $24

- medallions of bone in veal sautéed in our classic marsala sauce with fresh mushrooms.

Fish

“Catch of the Day” - $28

- local fish caught that day cooked Chef’s choice.


Lobster boiled, broiled or Fra Diavolo-

1 1/2lb- $36

2lb- $46

- local succulent lobster served with Balsam White corn and a baked potato.


Broiled Sea Scallops- $32

- locally caught scallops sautéed to perfection and served with risotto.


Seafood Cioppino- $32

- an assortment of locally caught fish in a fresh savory broth.

Beef

New York Strip- $36

- 12oz prime cut cooked to your liking with your choice of potato and steamed veggies.


Pork Chop- $25

- center cut chop grilled, broiled or pizzaiola with your choice of potato or risotto.

Other Than Italian

Craftburger- $14

- fresh ground beef cooked to order. Comes with fries.


Craftburger Deluxe- $15

- fresh ground beef cooked to order with your choice of cheese. Comes with fries.


Craftburger Italiano- $16

- fresh ground beef cooked to order with melted parmesan cheese and our homemade San Marzano sauce on ciabatta with parmesan fries

For the Kids - $10

Ziti with Butter or our homemade San Marzano sauce

Chicken Fingers with Fries


**Consuming raw or undercooked meats may
increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

 

House Desserts - $9

Cannoli

- homemade cannoli cream in the classic shell.


Tiramisu

- an Italian classic from our local baker.


Spumoni

- a favorite Italian ice cream dessert.


Zeppoli

- a classic Italian deep fried pastry


Drinks

Craft Beers

Guinness on Tap

Fine Cocktails

Select Wines

Sodas

Juices


Montauk Point LighthouseChicken Sandwich

Hours of Operation

Monday: 5:00 pm to Close
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 5:00 pm to Close
Friday: 5:00 pm to Close
Saturday: 5:00 pm to Close
Sunday: 12:00 pm to Close

Contact Info

  • 631-668-8424

  • info@josephinesmtk.com

  • 432 W Lake Drive 
    Montauk, NY 11954

Write Us

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Something went wrong while submitting the form!